By vs. With: What's the Difference? | Learn English Grammar for Beginners
Learn English with EnglishClass101.com · 2026-11-18
💡 Quick Take
1. The video explains how to use the English prepositions by and with using everyday examples and clear categories.
2. According to the host Daphne, the word by generally shows the doer of an action, a method of communication, a means of transport, or a deadline.
3. Daphne shows that the word with generally highlights a physical tool, an accompaniment or togetherness, a personal characteristic, or a specific manner.
4. A useful rule to remember is that you can often use both pay by card and pay with card, though by focuses on the general method and with focuses on the physical item.
📊 Detailed Explanation
The instructor breaks down the usage of by into several distinct categories to help beginners understand who or what is performing an action. First, by points to the agent in passive voice sentences, such as when a book is written by Charles Dickens or a person is attacked by a bear. Second, by indicates a method of communication, as seen in requests to send a document by email, by post, or by mail. Third, it describes a means of transport like traveling by car, by train, or by bus. Finally, by establishes a deadline, such as finishing a report by Friday or by Monday the fifth.
Next, the video explores the many ways to use the preposition with through practical everyday scenarios. With often points to a tool or instrument used to complete a task, such as cutting meat with a knife or opening a door with a key. It also expresses accompaniment or togetherness, like coming home with your wife or going to a party with your friends. Furthermore, with can describe a characteristic or feature, such as wanting a hotel room with a view or describing a man with glasses. Lastly, with indicates the manner in which something happens, illustrated by speaking with confidence or trembling with fear.
Toward the end of the lesson, Daphne addresses subtle nuances between the two words in specific contexts, such as payment methods. Learners often wonder whether to say pay by card or pay with card. The host clarifies that both phrases are natural and widely understood. However, paying by card focuses broadly on the general payment method, whereas paying with card draws slightly more attention to the physical item or card being handed over. This comparison gives learners the flexibility to use either option without worry.
🎯 Education Expert Opinion
Daphne presents grammar concepts by pairing every single rule with immediate, concrete examples written out on a board. This approach works well for visual learners and beginners because it anchors abstract prepositions to relatable objects like knives, keys, buses, and bears. Breaking the lesson into distinct functional categories keeps the cognitive load manageable for new English speakers.
To build on this lesson, learners should practice a substitution drill where they take a base sentence and swap out prepositions based on changing contexts. For instance, taking the sentence I traveled and changing the ending to by train versus with my family helps reinforce the core functional divide between transport and accompaniment. Creating personal sentences about daily routines provides the best bridge from passive listening to active production.
The main risk for beginners is overanalyzing minor prepositional variations and freezing up in conversation. The video wisely reassures learners that native speakers often accept overlapping usages, such as paying by card or with card, without a loss in clarity. Perfection is not required for successful communication.
The essential takeaway from this lesson is that prepositions are functional tools that describe relationships like agents, tools, and timelines. Keeping a mental picture of a physical tool for with and a general method or actor for by will help learners navigate everyday conversations with greater confidence.